Coaching Success — and Systemic Failure
They said it worked. The leader felt more empowered. Their team reported clearer communication. Goals were achieved faster. The coaching was praised.
But six months later, something cracked.
Team cohesion dropped. Turnover rose. A new initiative failed — despite strong leadership. Why?
Because while the individual grew, the system destabilized.
This is the coaching paradox: when helping one person can unintentionally hurt the whole.
Most Coaching Isn’t Systemic — And That’s a Problem
In most organizations, coaching is still centered on the individual:
- Performance improvement
- Leadership style refinement
- Personal mindset shifts
But organizations are systems — living, interconnected networks. Any change to one part affects the others.
When coaching ignores this, it can trigger:
- Role friction
- Informal power shifts
- Unprocessed envy or resistance
The result? A star performer… in a weakened system.
Systems Don’t Have Heroes — They Have Patterns
One of the most dangerous ideas in coaching is the “hero” model: elevate one person, and the rest will follow.
But systems don’t change because one person excels. They change when patterns shift — in relationships, power dynamics, and behavior loops.
Without addressing those patterns, even the best coaching creates fragmentation:
- A leader evolves, but the team feels abandoned
- A new behavior threatens unspoken agreements
- Power shifts without relational recalibration
That’s not transformation. It’s unintentional disruption.
The Risk of Isolated Transformation
Here’s how isolated coaching plays out:
- The coachee starts to grow — new insights, new behaviors
- Their environment doesn’t understand the shift
- Old roles get threatened — trust and connection fray
- The system compensates — subtly resisting the change
- The transformation stalls, or breaks something else
Change becomes personalized — and therefore, fragile.
What Systemic Coaching Really Looks Like
Systemic coaching isn’t about fixing people. It’s about listening to the system.
It starts with questions like:
- “What pattern is this person holding for the system?”
- “How will this shift ripple through the team?”
- “What is the system resisting, and why?”
Systemic coaching is relational, not positional. It works with culture, context, and tension — not just performance.
Case Study: The High Performer Who Broke the Team
A senior manager received executive coaching. Over six months, she became more decisive, boundary-aware, and ambitious. Her own results soared.
But something else happened. Her peers withdrew. Meetings got colder. A key collaborator resigned.
The coach had focused on her individual growth — but ignored how the team perceived her change as aggression and disconnection.
Eventually, she left — praised as a high-potential leader. But the system she left behind? Fractured.
Tools for Systemic Coaching Impact
Here’s how to coach individuals without damaging the system:
1. Map Roles & Relational Dependencies
Understand who this person is “carrying” in the system — what tensions, agreements, or shadows they hold.
2. Coach in Context
Always ask: How will this change affect others? What needs to be communicated or co-created?
3. Involve the System — Gently
Use team sessions, feedback loops, or constellation work to mirror systemic dynamics without blame.
4. Coach the Pattern, Not Just the Person
If a leader overfunctions, don’t just teach boundaries — ask why the system needs them to overfunction.
From Hero Work to System Work
The future of coaching isn’t better individual performance. It’s deeper systemic literacy.
That means:
- Seeing emotional roles, not just job titles
- Surfacing unspoken contracts, not just feedback gaps
- Tracking relational change, not just behavioral goals
Because if you change the person but not the pattern, the system will reject the change.
Conclusion: Don’t Just Coach the Leader. Coach the System.
The coaching paradox is real. You can help someone grow — and still break trust, coherence, or alignment if you ignore the system around them.
The solution? Shift from coaching people in isolation to coaching people as part of systems.
Because transformation isn’t just about how someone moves. It’s about how the system moves with them.
Explore More from Paradigm Red
Continue exploring at Paradigm Red